Arbitrator Ordered Developer to Pay $46.9 Million
The ruling impacts real estate operators by clarifying lender rights to insurance proceeds and loan advances.
Updated on Sept. 29, 2026 in Corporate Finance
Live Poll
Should developers be held strictly liable for contract disputes with their lenders?
An arbitrator has ordered developer Michael Stern and JDS to pay $46.9 million to Silverstein Capital Partners. The award follows findings that the developer diverted insurance proceeds and failed to account for vendor loan advances during the Brooklyn Tower project.
Why it matters
The ruling underscores the critical importance of strictly adhering to loan agreement security interests regarding insurance proceeds. For operators, this case serves as a warning on the consequences of mismanaging capital intended for vendors and the oversight risks associated with mezzanine debt.
The arbitration award totals $46.9 million plus 9 percent annual interest dating from September 2024. This follows a 2023 loan default on a total construction debt package that reached $664 million.
The players
Michael Stern
A real estate developer and leader of JDS, a firm known for large-scale luxury residential projects in New York City and Miami.
Silverstein Capital Partners
A real estate investment and lending firm that provides mezzanine financing for major commercial and residential construction projects.
Eugene Farber
The arbitrator tasked with presiding over the dispute between the developer and the lending firm.
The details
The arbitrator determined that Silverstein Capital Partners held a legal security interest in insurance proceeds, specifically relating to a 2022 burst water pipe at the Brooklyn Tower. The developer allegedly concealed a $35.4 million insurance payout and failed to account for $13.1 million in loan advances designated for vendors. The award resulted from the consolidation of competing claims filed by both parties in 2025.
Timeline
Silverstein Capital Partners provided a $240 million mezzanine loan in April 2019.
A burst water pipe occurred at the Brooklyn Tower in 2022.
JDS defaulted on its loan in 2023.
Annual interest on the award began accruing in September 2024.
The Brooklyn Tower project is expected to be completed by year-end 2026.
Market Landscape
This arbitration award is the latest development in the financial fallout following the 2023 default of JDS on its Brooklyn Tower loan. It reinforces the legal precedent that lenders maintain rigorous control over insurance proceeds and vendor-allocated funds within complex capital stacks.
Operators should review their loan covenants to ensure full transparency regarding insurance payouts and vendor-specific advances. Ensure all financial reporting aligns with lender security interests to avoid similar arbitration disputes.
The takeaway
This case highlights the extreme financial and reputational risk inherent in failing to account for specific loan allocations. Operators should prioritize rigorous internal audit trails for all construction-related capital to ensure compliance with lender agreements.
Further reading
For more insight into how lenders manage risk during construction delays, see Corporate Finance.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Real Deal New York.
Live Poll
Should developers be held strictly liable for contract disputes with their lenders?
